Zapier vs Make and Which Automation Tool Fits Your Budget
You have a repetitive job to automate, such as copying form entries into a spreadsheet or posting new orders to a team chat, and every guide points you at the same two names.

You have a repetitive job to automate, such as copying form entries into a spreadsheet or posting new orders to a team chat, and every guide points you at the same two names. The Zapier vs Make question looks like a feature comparison, but for most small teams it really comes down to two things: how many steps your workflows have, and how much time you will spend building them.
I have built the same handful of automations in both tools for clients over the past few years. Neither is better across the board. They are priced differently, they think about workflows differently, and those differences decide which one ends up cheaper and less frustrating for you.
Zapier vs Make in one paragraph
Zapier is built around a simple list: a trigger, then a series of actions, one under the other. It connects to more apps than anything else, around 7,000 at the time of writing, and someone with no technical background can usually build a working automation in 15 minutes. Make, formerly Integromat, uses a visual canvas where steps are circles joined by lines. It handles branching, loops and data reshaping far better, connects to fewer apps (still well over 2,000), and costs much less per step. The tradeoff is a steeper learning curve.
How the pricing really compares
This is where most comparisons go wrong, because the two tools count usage differently.
- Zapier counts tasks. Every action that runs successfully is one task. The trigger is free. A three action automation that fires 100 times uses 300 tasks.
- Make counts operations. Every module that runs, including the trigger and each check for new data, is one operation. The same workflow uses roughly 400 operations, plus extra for scheduled polling.
Even with that difference, Make usually works out cheaper. Here is a rough picture based on published plans at the time of writing. Check the current pricing pages before you commit, because both companies adjust plans often.
| Plan level | Zapier | Make |
|---|---|---|
| Free | 100 tasks a month, two step automations only | 1,000 operations a month, multi step allowed |
| Entry paid | About 20 dollars a month for 750 tasks | About 9 to 11 dollars a month for 10,000 operations |
| Schedule frequency | Every 15 minutes on entry plans | As often as every minute |
A worked example. A small shop sends every new order to a spreadsheet, a chat channel and an email to the warehouse: three actions, 400 orders a month. On Zapier that is 1,200 tasks, which pushes past the entry tier. On Make it is about 1,600 operations, comfortably inside the cheapest paid plan. At that volume the gap is often 30 to 50 dollars a month.
Where each tool wins
Pick Zapier when
- The person building and maintaining automations is not technical and will not have time to learn.
- You rely on a niche app. Zapier's catalogue often has an integration when nobody else does.
- Your workflows are short and linear: when this happens, do that, then that.
- Volume is low, under a few hundred runs a month, so the per task cost barely matters.
Pick Make when
- A workflow needs to branch, for example sending refunds one way and new orders another.
- You process lists, such as every line item on an invoice, which Make handles with built in iterators.
- You need to call an app that has no ready integration. Make's HTTP module and webhook tools are easier to use than Zapier's equivalents. If webhooks are new to you, start with our explainer on what a webhook is and when to use one.
- Volume is high or growing, so cost per step really adds up.
Do not pick on app count alone
The common advice is to choose whichever tool lists the most integrations. That sounds sensible, but it rarely decides anything for a small business. The apps most teams use, such as Google Sheets, Gmail, Slack, Shopify, Stripe, HubSpot, Calendly and Typeform, are covered by both tools.
What matters more is how deep each integration goes. An app can appear in a catalogue with only two triggers and one action, which is useless if the action you need is missing. Before choosing, write down the exact trigger and action for your top three workflows, then search each tool's app page for those specific events. That ten minute check is worth more than any headline number.
The second thing app counts hide is failure handling. Make lets you add error routes to any module, so a failed step can retry, log, or alert you. Zapier offers auto replay on paid plans and simple error paths, which are fine for basic flows but harder to tune. For anything involving money or customer messages, test how each tool behaves when an app is briefly down.
A quick way to decide
Spend one hour with each tool's free plan and build your single most important workflow in both. Note three things:
- How long it took to get a working run.
- How many tasks or operations one run used, shown in each tool's history view.
- Whether you could read the finished workflow a week later and understand it.
The third point is underrated. Automations tend to be built once and then forgotten until they break, often months later. A Zapier list reads top to bottom like a recipe, which helps a colleague fix it. A Make scenario shows the whole flow at a glance, but only if you name each module clearly instead of leaving the defaults.
Multiply the usage by your expected monthly runs and compare it with the plan tables. If Zapier took 15 minutes and Make took an hour, and the monthly difference is 10 dollars, Zapier is likely the better choice for you. If the difference is 60 dollars and you are comfortable on the canvas, Make wins.
Whatever you pick, try to keep everything in one tool. Running both doubles the logins, the billing and the places a broken automation can hide, a problem we cover in the hidden cost of too many tools. For a wider view of the decision, our guide to choosing automation tools without overcomplicating it covers when you need neither.
Frequently asked questions
Is Make cheaper than Zapier?
For most workflows with more than one or two steps, yes. Make's entry plan includes far more operations per dollar than Zapier's tasks, even though Make counts the trigger. For very simple, low volume automations the difference may be only a few dollars a month.
Is Make harder to learn than Zapier?
A little. The visual canvas and terms like modules, bundles and iterators take a few sessions to feel natural. Most people who can build a spreadsheet formula are comfortable within a week of occasional use.
Can I move my automations from Zapier to Make?
There is no one click import, so each workflow has to be rebuilt by hand. Plan the switch app by app, run the new version alongside the old one for a few days, and turn off the original only once the results match.
More in Automation Tools
Automation Tools
Automation Tool Pricing: Tasks vs Operations Explained
A reader wrote to me in September because she had signed up for a plan with 750 tasks a month, built two small workflows, and...
Automation Tools
Choosing a No Code Database for Small Team Automations
Every automation I have helped someone build eventually hits the same wall.
Automation Tools
Scheduling Link Tools and How to Pick One Without Overpaying
The email thread started on Monday. "Does Thursday work?" "Thursday is tight, how about Friday morning?" "Friday I can do after...